TL;DR: An 18-person independent insurance brokerage in Charlotte, NC has 1,800 active policies. Roughly 150 renew each month. The operations manager prints a renewal report, distributes sections to five account managers, and follows up to see who's been called. In practice: the list goes under the keyboard. Account managers contact 40-45% of renewing clients before the renewal date. The other 55-60% either auto-renew without the brokerage adding any value, or lapse without anyone knowing until the commission report shows a gap 30 days later. Last year: 288 policies lost, 176 without a single outreach call, $168,000 in commissions. We designed a four-stage agent that monitors renewals continuously, creates AM tasks with full client context at 90 days, sends automated client outreach at 60 and 30 days if no AM contact, and escalates high-value uncontacted renewals to the ops manager. Running cost: $29-$62/month.
First of the Month
First of the month. Dana opens Applied Epic. Runs the renewal report: policies expiring in the next 60 days. A hundred and forty-seven policies this month.
She exports to a spreadsheet. Sorts by account manager. Prints five sections. Walks them to each AM's desk.
"Here's your renewals for the next 60 days."
The AMs look at the list. They have good intentions. They also have 6 pending claims, 4 new business quotes to write, and a stack of endorsement requests that arrived this morning. The renewal list goes under the keyboard.
Week 1: 3 renewal calls made. Week 2: 8 more. A few clients called in on their own after getting carrier renewal notices. Week 3: Dana asks for a progress update. One AM has contacted 22 of 31 clients. Another has contacted 9 of 38. A third has contacted 4 of 29 ("it's been a crazy month"). Week 4: the remaining uncontacted clients either auto-renew (the brokerage adds nothing to the transaction) or they don't renew (the brokerage finds out 30 days later from the commission report).
Dana reconciles at month end. Of 147 renewals due: 62 were contacted by an AM before renewal. 65 auto-renewed without contact. 12 lapsed or moved to another agency. 8 are still pending.
The 12 that left? Nobody called them. Nobody knows why they left. One of them was a $14,000 commercial account. The principal broker found out when the commission didn't appear. The conversation with the AM was, by Dana's recollection, uncomfortable.
This is, when stated precisely, a business whose entire revenue model is recurring commissions, tracked by printing a list once a month and distributing it to five people who have every intention of calling and insufficient time to follow through. The intentions are genuine. The system for converting intentions into phone calls does not exist.
The Brokerage
Independent insurance brokerage in Charlotte, North Carolina. Eighteen employees. $2.8M in annual commission revenue. Roughly 1,800 active policies: 680 commercial, 1,120 personal lines. Average commission per policy: $1,850 per year for commercial, $420 for personal.
Dana is the operations manager. She spends 4-6 hours per month generating and distributing the renewal report, following up with AMs on progress, and reconciling what actually renewed. Annual cost of her tracking time: $7,200 to $10,800. Modest. The tracking cost is not the problem. The tracking's failure to produce consistent contact is.
Renewal retention rate over the prior 12 months: 84% overall (88% commercial, 81% personal). Industry benchmark for agencies this size: 90-93%. The gap: 6-9 points below benchmark. Applied to 1,800 policies, that gap produced 288 lost policies and approximately $168,000 in lost commissions.
Policies where the AM made contact before renewal: roughly 40-45%. Policies that renewed without any outreach from the brokerage (client auto-renewed or the carrier processed it): 55-60%. The brokerage provided zero additional value on more than half of its renewals. The client renewed despite the brokerage, not because of it.
The 176 policies that lapsed without a phone call weren't lost to bad service or uncompetitive pricing. They were lost to a list that competed with claims, quotes, endorsements, and a phone that doesn't stop ringing. The renewal calls were important. They were never the most urgent thing on any given day. And tasks that are important but never urgent are the tasks that drift until it's too late.
The design is next. The design, the build guide, the running costs and the take-away are free to subscribers. Enter your email below and the rest of this Blueprint opens. New ones arrive every Tuesday and Friday.
